For instance, take this metacity commit : Change default cycle_group keybinding to Alt-grave. This change looks perfectly harmless, right ? Well not quite. It’s most likely based on the assumption that the end users has a qwerty keyboard layout (and it makes perfectly sense there). But let’s take an azerty layout. Grave is on the é/7 key, which is even farther from alt or tab than F6 is (well, not much I agree, but it might be even worse on other layouts). Is it really worth doing such a change then ?

Let’s also note that this also triggers a bad bug which gets alt+7 and alt+shift+7 to trigger the binding as well, while alt+grave is actually alt+altgr+7. This has been keeping me from nicely switching to my window n°7 in irssi for months (great thing that this window holds a really low traffic channel…).

All in all, I guess that the real problem is not that this change was made, but rather than we might need a system to have layout-dependant keybindings, or maybe hardware-location-based keybindings (i.e. that the key above the Tab key would trigger this keybinding independently of the layout).

Initially published on Mar 24, 2010 @ 8:22

Update : this change has been reverted for the GNOME 2.30 release. Even though I’m happy that the problem is “fixed”, it’s sad that the underlying problem (Alt+Shift+7 triggering Alt+`) is still there.

Wondering how it looks? Here is the output of a little test:

ixce@timmy:~$ sudo shutdown -r
W: molly-guard: SSH session detected!
Please type in hostname of the machine to shutdown:
Good thing I asked; I won't shutdown timmy ...

Since it doesn’t correctly handle sudo yet (actually sudo is at fault here, since it drops SSH_CONNECTION environment variable when doing its stuff), you might want to add PRETEND_SSH around the beginning of /usr/sbin/shutdown as specified on Nico “nion” Golde’s blog.

You might also want to grab the molly-guard 0.3.2 etch package I backported from sid (all I changed is downgrade debhelper build-dep version and debhelper compatibility level in debian/compat since etch only has debhelper 5 and the sid package required debhelper 6 ; this shouldn’t break anything since the newer debhelper just seems to be needed to recognize a few fields in debian/control about where the package is maintained). Sources are also available, anyway.

Thanks hr for the tip

On a side note, we are about to release Compiz Fusion 0.6.0 (and 0.6.2 should follow rather quickly to match the upcoming Compiz bugfix release).

Actions are no grouped in a single tab, ordered in a treeview, but they can be grouped in tabs and subgrouped in expanders as other settings. A small icon in front of actions’ label indicate the type of the action, and custom widgets were developed, among which a screen edge selector, a keyboard modifiers selector and a key grabber (which is able to grab Tab keys and such).

All graphics are courtesy of the GNOME project, thanks guys for the great work !.

Read more for some screenshots.

Overall look of actions in a normal options tab :

Close-up on the brand new edge selector :

Likewise, close-up on the new mouse button selector :

And the original mockup of the mouse button selector by Dennis “onestone” :